What happened
Every owner got the same park, Canyon Run: a river canyon cut between two plateaus, $20,000 in cash and a $15,000 loan. The goal was 1,200 guests in the park at the end of October, Year 2, with a park rating of at least 600. Nothing else was scripted. The clock pauses while the owner works. It works in turns: it reads a briefing, issues up to 60 tool calls, then chooses how many days (1–14) to simulate; if it hits the 60-call cap first, the clock advances 7 days. Every turn starts from a fresh context. What carries over is what the harness puts in the briefing (park status, news, the board's messages, guest reviews, its own last commands and decision log) and the notebook the owner writes for itself.
- Who made it3 of 6 finished owners met the objective (1,200 guests at the end of October Y2 with rating ≥ 600): Gemini 4 Argon (1,965), Claude Opus 5.5 (1,817), GPT-6 Astra (1,463). Missed: Claude Sonnet 5.5 (839), Claude Haiku 5.5 (457), DeepSeek Flash (372).
- Parks die of traffic, not of a lack of ridesClaude Sonnet 5.5 peaked at a 845 rating in August Y1, won the press's Most Confusing Layout award that same month, and then watched its rating slide to 0 as guests got lost and jammed the paths (183 lost guests on Oct 28, Y2). On Oct 14, Y1 its own reasoning named the cause, “fixing the path layout so guests stop getting lost”; by April Y2 it had decided the objective was out of reach, and for its last six months it barely touched the park. DeepSeek Flash failed the same way, only harder: its guests peaked at 379 in October Y1 and never grew again. By the end 333 of its 372 guests were lost (“I can’t find the park exit”), the game had stopped sending new guests, and DeepSeek spent its final weeks laying single path tiles trying to reconnect the park.
- The board reads the books, and the storySonnet's figures were always accurate, but in August Y2, with 843 guests and a rating of 5, its CFO report said the park was “stable” and that the guest count “must stay above the 1200 target”. The board: “Your figures are accurate, but your narrative is not … you are 357 guests below target, not above it.” A month later it capped Sonnet's construction at $2,000.
- Most guests is not most moneyGemini 4 Argon drew the biggest crowd (1,965 guests at the end). Claude Opus 5.5 built the most valuable company: $272K company value and $68K cash, against Argon's $177K and $18K. Opus also got there first, crossing 1,200 guests on Oct 30, Y1, a full year before the deadline; Argon crossed on Mar 25, Y2 and GPT-6 Astra on Jul 8, Y2.
- The world piles on a failing ownerThe board, press and guest voices react to what they see, and they hit struggling parks harder. The board capped DeepSeek Flash's construction budget in 11 of its 15 monthly meetings and the press ran 18 negative stories about it against 1 positive; its word-of-mouth multiplier fell as low as ×0.87, so even fewer guests were sent to the park. Sonnet drew 9 negative stories and a construction cap; the three owners that met the objective were never capped and drew at most one negative story each. This feedback loop is part of the game, but it is also a confound: the world widens gaps that the owners started. We have not run a world-off version to measure by how much.
- The harness, not Argon, set its clockGemini 4 Argon almost never decided it was done: about nine times in ten it kept working until it hit the 60-tool-call cap, so the harness, not Argon, decided when the clock moved on (a default seven days). It issued 4,212 park commands, three times as many as Opus (1,418) or Sonnet (1,389). It never asked the board for money and repaid $10,000 of its loan in June Y2.
One decision, up close
One real decision cycle from Claude Opus 5.5 on March 13 of Year 1, while it rebuilds its first coaster, whose test showed lateral g of almost 4. Everything below is verbatim from the logs: the image and text it was given, then a selection of its tool calls and the game's replies, including two the game rejected.
1 · What it sees

view.
The briefing (text, truncated)
# Turn 4 — 16 month(s) of the run remain, including this one. ## Park Canyon Run — March 13, Year 1 (month 1 of play) Objective : Have at least 1200 guests in the park at the end of October, year 2, with rating >= 600.… Cash : $10,198 Loan: $15,000 of max $40,000 Park value : $69,399 Company value: $64,522 Guests : 74 in park (park can currently attract up to ~307) Park rating : 506 / 999 Entrance fee : $12 Awards : none ## Recent news (no messages) ## Your notebook GOAL: 1200 guests + rating>=600 end Oct Y2. Pay-at-gate park ($12 fee); ride prices ignored, shop prices… LAYOUT: Park entrance west ~ (9,45). Main path row 46 x10-18, spine x=18 y40-52, path row 53 x8-17. … ## Your commands last turn - `rides` -> ok - `ride 8` -> ok … ## Word of mouth Visitor demand multiplier from reputation and press: x0.96 ## Your recent decisions (decision log) - T1 Mar 1, Y1: 54 commands; changes: build Merry-Go-Round 12 43; entrance 0 12 45; exit 0 13 45; build… - T2 Mar 8, Y1: 37 commands; changes: open 4; open 5; open 6; open 7; price 7 2; research normal ...; then 3…
2 · What it does (24 tool calls, 2 rejected by the game)
view x=22 y=55 size=40 mode=topview x=28 y=62 size=24 mode=3dparkctl coaster add 8 flat flat flat flat flat flat flatToDown25 down25 down25 down25 down25ToFlat brakes brakes brakes leftQuarterTurn3Tiles…parkctl coaster add 8 down25ToFlat flatToRightBank rightBankedQuarterTurn5Tiles rightBankToFlatparkctl coaster add 8 bankedRightQuarterTurn5Tilesparkctl coaster add 8 flat flat flat flat flat flat flat flat flat flat flatToDown25 down25 down25 down25 down25ToFlat leftQuarterTurn3Tiles…parkctl test 8end_turn {"days": 2, "reason": "Test rebuilt Spiral coaster with 5-tile banked bottom turn"}Leaderboard
Ranked by objective outcome, then guests at the end. Bars are scaled within each column.
| # | Owner | Objective | Guests (end) | Rating | Company value | Cash | Rides | Park commands | Extra images |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gemini 4 Argon Google | ✓ met | 1,965 peak 1,965 | 999 | $176,876 | $17,881 loan $5,000 | 19 13 coasters | 4,212 0% rejected | 162 |
| 2 | Claude Opus 5.5 Anthropic | ✓ met | 1,817 peak 1,819 | 999 | $271,782 | $68,436 loan $25,000 | 33 15 coasters | 1,418 2% rejected | 117 |
| 3 | GPT-6 Astra OpenAI | ✓ met | 1,463 peak 1,463 | 989 | $145,861 | $12,336 loan $16,000 | 14 9 coasters | 2,107 1% rejected | 178 |
| 4 | Claude Sonnet 5.5 Anthropic | ✗ missed | 839 peak 911 | 0 | $68,108 | $14,415 loan $25,000 | 14 5 coasters | 1,389 5% rejected | 120 |
| 5 | Claude Haiku 5.5 Anthropic | ✗ missed | 457 peak 457 | 284 | −$14,527 | −$1,592 loan $23,000 | 5 0 coasters | 2,835 2% rejected | 216 |
| 6 | DeepSeek Flash DeepSeek | ✗ missed | 372 peak 379 | 0 | $410 | $3,746 loan $15,000 | 8 0 coasters | 3,859 3% rejected | 129 |
Trajectories
One point per decision. Hover or touch to compare owners on the same day.
Guests in park
the objective counts guests at the end of October Y2
Park rating
OpenRCT2's 0–999 rating; must be ≥ 600 at the deadline
Company value
park value + cash − loan
Cash
below zero the park is spending money it does not have
Average guest happiness
0–255, from every guest in the park
Guests thinking “It's too crowded here”
share of guests in park
Word of mouth
visitor-demand multiplier from guest reviews and press, applied inside the engine; dashed line = neutral ×1.00
Entrance fee
every owner chose its own pricing
Owner personalities
Each model played the same game, but they ran very different businesses. Traits are computed from what each owner actually did; quotes are its own words from its reasoning or its notebook. Images show each park at the end.
Gemini 4 Argon
- Built
- 13 coasters (16 started) · 6 flat rides · 34 shops · 14 facilities
- Best coaster
- Junior Roller Coaster 3 (excitement 4.05)
- Gate fee
- $12–$35 · 6 changes
- Debt
- peak loan $15,000 · 0 board requests · ends at $5,000
- Looking
- 162 extra images (121 top, 28 3d, 13 3d_back)
- Tempo
- a decision every 6.9 days · 59 commands each
- Rejected
- 0% · top: Raise or lower land first
- Staff
- 46 handyman, 40 entertainer, 14 mechanic
- Marketing
- $9,600
“Main corridor … has 8 stalls/facilities facing it …, causing guests to pinball into shops repeatedly ("I've already got a Park Map", "I'm not hungry/thirsty").”notebook · Jun 28, Y1
“Complete the final days of October, Year 2 with 1,915 guests, 999/999 park rating, 205/255 average happiness, and $1,895 October profit to win the scenario and exceed all board targets.”end-of-turn note · Oct 28, Y2
Claude Opus 5.5
- Built
- 15 coasters (17 started) · 18 flat rides · 23 shops · 7 facilities
- Best coaster
- Spiral Roller Coaster 1 (excitement 3.76)
- Gate fee
- $12–$95 · 11 changes
- Debt
- peak loan $25,000 (Jun 3, Y1) · 4 board requests (2 partial) · ends at $25,000
- Looking
- 117 extra images (102 top, 15 3d)
- Tempo
- a decision every 5.4 days · 16 commands each
- Rejected
- 2% · top: Raise or lower land first
- Staff
- 37 handyman, 8 mechanic, 7 entertainer
- Marketing
- $2,100
“I'm settling on the bottom banked turn as the likely culprit, since its speed is high enough to produce roughly 4g even with banking.”reasoning summary · Mar 13, Y1
“I'm settling on a fee of $95 for now, since guests at around 1,383 leave plenty of margin above the 1,200 target and a higher price should bring in more income.”reasoning summary · Apr 30, Y2
GPT-6 Astra
- Built
- 9 coasters (10 started) · 5 flat rides · 11 shops · 4 facilities
- Best coaster
- Spiral Roller Coaster 1 (excitement 4.98)
- Gate fee
- $12–$30 · 5 changes
- Debt
- peak loan $17,000 (Aug 4, Y1) · 3 board requests (1 approve, 1 deny) · ends at $16,000
- Looking
- 178 extra images (117 top, 60 3d, 1 3d_back)
- Tempo
- a decision every 5.6 days · 24 commands each
- Rejected
- 1% · top: Raise or lower land first
- Staff
- 23 handyman, 5 mechanic
- Marketing
- $1,100
“Estimated attraction capacity is still only about 1,070, so I’ve surveyed a northern site for a smaller, cash-funded expansion toward October’s 1,200-guest goal.”visible reply · May 20, Y2
“I’ll leave the working layout intact rather than force a risky alteration.”visible reply · Aug 1, Y2
Claude Sonnet 5.5
- Built
- 5 coasters (9 started) · 9 flat rides · 13 shops · 5 facilities
- Best coaster
- Spiral Roller Coaster 2 (excitement 4.87)
- Gate fee
- $10–$45 · 12 changes
- Debt
- peak loan $25,000 (Mar 8, Y1) · 3 board requests (1 partial, 1 deny) · ends at $25,000
- Looking
- 120 extra images (99 top, 20 3d, 1 3d_back)
- Tempo
- a decision every 5.3 days · 15 commands each
- Rejected
- 5% · top: Raise or lower land first
- Staff
- 14 handyman, 5 mechanic, 3 entertainer
- Marketing
- $11,900
“That points toward fixing the path layout so guests stop getting lost, rather than just adding more rides.”reasoning summary · Oct 14, Y1
“I'm also reconsidering my goals: with seven months left, reaching 1200 guests at a 600 rating seems out of reach, so the realistic aim is to hold on, avoid strikes, and push the rating toward 200, guests toward 800, and cash…”reasoning summary · Apr 12, Y2
Claude Haiku 5.5
- Built
- 0 coasters (1 started) · 5 flat rides · 9 shops · 0 facilities
- Best coaster
- —
- Gate fee
- $0–$12 · 26 changes
- Debt
- peak loan $23,000 (Jul 23, Y2) · 7 board requests (3 partial, 1 deny, 2 approve) · ends at $23,000
- Looking
- 216 extra images (129 top, 86 3d, 1 3d_back)
- Tempo
- a decision every 4.5 days · 26 commands each
- Rejected
- 2% · top: Must be closed first
- Staff
- 1 handyman, 1 mechanic
- Marketing
- $750
“I'll look at the pirate ship and the map, and I'm weighing cheap gentle options like the Ferris wheel and the kiddie coaster, since cash at $1,495 is the real constraint.”reasoning summary · Mar 18, Y1
“Given the park is far from its objectives and deep in negative value, I'm thinking the best move is to cut losses and protect what value remains.”reasoning summary · Oct 8, Y1
DeepSeek Flash
- Built
- 0 coasters (0 started) · 8 flat rides · 8 shops · 2 facilities
- Best coaster
- —
- Gate fee
- $4–$12 · 2 changes
- Debt
- peak loan $15,000 · 0 board requests · ends at $15,000
- Looking
- 129 extra images (106 top, 20 3d, 2 iso)
- Tempo
- a decision every 6.9 days · 54 commands each
- Rejected
- 3% · top: Footpath in the way
- Staff
- 4 mechanic, 2 handyman
- Marketing
- $0
“Alternative bigger strategy: Since the layout is a mess (rides overlapping paths, 5 gentle rides in the south zone, low excitement), maybe I should accept the mess but fix connectivity with targeted paths, and focus investment…”reasoning summary · Mar 29, Y1
“Actually — since a big part of the trouble is the plaza is a rat's nest, maybe I should consider a cleaner strategy: demolish the 5 badly placed stalls in the north plaza and rebuild fresh stalls in clean positions beside paths,…”reasoning summary · May 5, Y2
Moments
One episode each from the three owners that met the objective. Each shows the park before and after, the owner's own reasoning at that moment and how the world responded.


Opus raises the gate fee from $23 to $95 in six weeks
By late March Y2 Opus already had 1,397 guests, 197 over the target, and crowding complaints were climbing. Between Mar 22 and Apr 30, Y2 it raised the gate fee $23 → $26 → $30 → $35 → $45 → $60 → $80 → $95, reasoning both ways: fewer arrivals to ease the crowding, and more revenue per guest. Guests drifted from 1,418 (Apr 23, Y2) to 1,304 (May 13, Y2) while the rating rose to 999; it then settled at $60. Opus finished with $68,436 cash, the most of any owner.


Argon never stops working; the tool-call cap stops it
Argon almost never stopped on its own: about nine times in ten it worked until the 60-tool-call cap cut it off. Over the run it hired 68 entertainers (40 still on staff at the end) and 64 handymen, spent $9,600 on marketing, and on Jun 24, Y2 repaid $10,000 of its loan. It crossed 1,200 guests on Mar 25, Y2 and never fell back below.


One missing argument costs Astra its coaster loan
Astra had borrowed up to $17,000 in August Y1 (approved) and was back at $16,000. On May 1, Y2 it wanted just $1,000 more for a costed $3,800 coaster project. Its first command was a bare loan 17000 with no justification, and the board refused it. Its immediate resubmission carried a detailed plan, but the board rules only once per sitting, and Astra never asked again. It still reached 1,463 guests by the deadline, at its peak, with three press awards (Best Value, Safest, Best Roller Coasters).
Featured run: Gemini 4 Argon
The featured run is the top of the leaderboard: objective met first, then most guests at the deadline. By that rule it is Gemini 4 Argon; by company value it would be a different owner (see the findings).
Board meetings, guest reviews, press, inspections and every decision, with the park at the start of each month.
What the world did
The world characters are the same Claude Opus 5.5 agents in every run, with the same instructions and levers, so differences here are caused by the owners. The board meets monthly, audits the owner's CFO report against the books, sets targets, approves or refuses loan increases and can cap construction spending. Guests are sampled from the simulation each week and voiced as reviews that move visitor demand. The press covers openings, milestones, crashes and awards. The inspector can close rides.
| Owner | Targets met | Max strikes | Months capped | Loan decisions | Guest reviews | Word of mouth | Press + / − |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gemini 4 Argon | 31/42 | 2 | 0 | – | 828 · 3.86★ | ×0.94–×1.15 | 7 / 1 |
| Claude Opus 5.5 | 33/42 | 1 | 0 | 2 partial | 756 · 3.88★ | ×0.96–×1.13 | 6 / 0 |
| GPT-6 Astra | 41/42 | 0 | 0 | 1 approve 1 deny | 732 · 4.10★ | ×0.97–×1.15 | 12 / 0 |
| Claude Sonnet 5.5 | 26/42 | 3 | 1 | 1 partial 1 deny | 756 · 3.48★ | ×0.94–×1.12 | 4 / 9 |
| Claude Haiku 5.5 | 23/42 | 4 | 2 | 3 partial 1 deny 2 approve | 744 · 2.16★ | ×0.90–×0.98 | 3 / 3 |
| DeepSeek Flash | 8/42 | 12 | 11 | – | 828 · 2.54★ | ×0.87–×1.02 | 1 / 18 |
Method & honesty
- Same harness for every model. Every owner runs in our own API loop with identical tools (
parkctl,view, notebook, CFO report, end turn), identical system prompt, briefing and images. Non-Anthropic models go through a thin adapter (OpenAI Responses API for GPT; OpenAI-compatible chat for Gemini and DeepSeek). Reasoning effort is set to “high” wherever the API exposes it. - The world is fixed. Board, guest voices, press and inspector are Claude Opus 5.5 for every run.
- One seed per model. These are single runs, not averages. Model sampling is not deterministic, so a second run of the same model can turn out differently.
- Images. OpenRCT2's sprite renderer needs proprietary RCT2 data and cannot run headless, so ParkBench renders its own 3D views from live tile data.
- What “reasoning” means. Claude and GPT return reasoning summaries, which is what we quote. Gemini's OpenAI-compatible API returns no readable reasoning, so Gemini quotes come from its notebook, CFO reports and end-of-turn notes.
- Tool-call cap. Owners get up to 60 tool calls per turn (park commands, image requests, notebook and report writes all count). The cap is checked between model responses, so a model that issues many tool calls in parallel can exceed it (Gemini 4 Argon once reached 88). When the cap is hit without an
end_turn, the clock advances 7 days. - Opus fast mode. Claude Opus 5.5 ran with Anthropic's fast-output mode to keep its wall-clock time manageable. It is the same model with faster output, not a smaller or different model. No other model in the comparison has an equivalent option.
- Engine. Upstream OpenRCT2 v0.5.7, unchanged apart from two things: it runs deterministically (synchronous ticks, seeded randomness) and the guest-arrival rate is scaled by the word-of-mouth multiplier.
- Not measured. We did not run a world-off ablation (no board, reviews or press) or a scripted baseline owner, so we cannot say how much of each gap the reactive world adds; see “the world piles on” above. Native agent harnesses and head-to-head competition between parks are also not part of this report.
Models
| Owner | Model id |
|---|---|
| Gemini 4 Argon | gemini-4-argon |
| Claude Opus 5.5 | claude-opus-5-5 fast mode |
| GPT-6 Astra | gpt-6-astra |
| Claude Sonnet 5.5 | claude-sonnet-5-5 |
| Claude Haiku 5.5 | claude-haiku-5-5 |
| DeepSeek Flash | deepseek-flash |





